According to the WHO, 30% of health expenditures are wasted on inefficient care and avoidable complications.
The Consortium Résultat Patient is dedicated to the emergence of real-world data registries that measure the value of care according to standardised indicators that matter to patients.
One of the major weaknesses of health systems is that they measure treatment inputs rather than patient outcomes.
To address this, the Consortium Résultat Patient accelerates the emergence of real-world data registries measuring patients’ health gains and Value-Based Health Care (VBHC).
The Consortium includes public and private institutions committed to:
- involving patients in health care evaluation (quality of life, functional recovery)
- allowing clinicians to compare themselves and improve their practices
- making health outcomes visible to all stakeholders
- helping patients navigate the health system and identify high-value care
The Value-Based Health Care (VBHC) approach measures patient outcomes relative to money spent.
Patient outcomes refer to a functional recovery and quality of life composite score.
- This score is measured through psychometric surveys scientifically validated.
- Patients' health gains, of clinical benefits, result from the score difference before, during and after treatment
- Scores are adjusted to patients' profiles, according to comorbidities and complications.
- This comparative analysis of real-world health gains identifies which care pathway generates the highest value for a specific patient profile and for the health system.
The Consortium Résultat Patient was mandated by the European Union to publish a report in 2020 on the implementation of VBHC ecosystems.
Based on an analysis of 250 interviews of VBHC leaders across 22 EU countries, the handbook captures VBHC best practices. It offers a structured roadmap for implementation and presents case studies to help give rise to ecosystems based on high-value care.
interviews of VBHC leaders
EU countries analyzed
visits of pioneering sites
The Consortium is participating in the VBHC cataract experiment led by PromTime, funded by the French Ministry of Health and the National payer, the Assurance Maladie.
The experiment evaluates the appropriateness and transparency of cataract surgeries performed in the Nantes and Limoges regions.
This experiment introduces two pioneering innovations (Decree published in the Journal Officiel de la République Française on July 30, 2020):
- The open benchmark of average health gainsof participating clinicians
- An incentive payment for practitioners who share patients' health gains: The Financial Incentive for Advanced Transparency (FIAT)
Management team
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
President, Consortium Résultat Patient
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Member of the Transparency Commission, HAS
Marie-Josée Augé-Caumon
Honorary President
Treasurer of the Pharmacy National Professional Council
Florent Perin Dureau
Anesthesiologist, Medical advisor Rest Therapeutics
Former director of the neuroscience department, ANSM
Former director of research, Hôpital Foch
Supervisory Board
Anne-Marie Armanteras
President of the Supervisory Board, Consortium Résultat Patient
President, ANAP; former commission chair HAS, former DGOS, former health advisor to the President of the French Republic
Pr. Laurent Degos
Founder and first President, HAS
Member of Académie des sciences
Pr. Isabelle Durand-Zaleski
Director, Health Economics Clinical Research Unit (APHP)
Former head of the evaluation department, HAS
Member of the Scientific Council, ATIH
Peter Pitts
President, Center for Medicine in the Public Interest
Former FDA Deputy Commissioner
Scientific Advisory Board for the Cataract Registry
Pr. Béatrice Cochener
President of the National Council of Ophthalmology Professionals
Ophtalmology Department, Brest University Hospital
Dr. Vincent Dédes
President of the Syndicat National des Ophtalmologistes de France (National Union of Ophthalmologists of France)
Cabinet d’Ophtalmologie des Flandres
Dr. François Lignereux
President of the Scientific Council
Institut Ophtalmologique Sourdille-Atlantique
Pr. Dominique Monnet
Vice President de la SAFIR
Ophthalmology department, APHP Cochin Hospital
Dr. Pascal Rozot
President of the SAFIR (Society of the French Association of Implants and Refractive Surgery)
Ophthalmologist
Pr. Michel Weber
Chief of the Ophthalmology department, Nantes University Hospital
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
President of the Consortium
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Scientific Advisory Board for the Carpal Tunnel Registry
Dr Philippe Bellemère
Former President of the French Society of Hand Surgery (SFCM)
Institut de la main santé Atlantique, Nantes
Dr Camilo Chaves
Hand surgeon
Clinique du Pré, Le Mans, Clinique Ambroise Paré, Neuilly sur Seine
Dr Thierry Dubert
Chairman of the Scientific Board
Hôpital Privé Paul d’Egine, Champigny sur Marnes
Mr Cédric Girault
Administrative manager & medical-social advisor
Réseau Prévention Main Ile de France
Dr Yves Jacob
Chairman of the Legal Commission, SFCM
Clinique Claude Bernard, Metz
Pr Laurent Obert
1st Vice President, SFCM
Head of Department, Besançon University Hospital
Dr Patrick Théron
President CDOM 94, Secretary General CNOM, Honorary President, Réseau Prévention Main Ile de France
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
President of the Consortium
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Scientific Advisory Board for the Maternity Registry
Pr. Patrick Rozenberg
President CNGOF
American Hospital of Paris
Pr. Philippe Deruelle
Secretary general, CNP GOGM
PU-PH, CHU Montpellier
Pr. Corinne Dupont
Vice-Dean of Maieutics, HCL
Faculty of Medicine, Claude Bernard Lyon 1 University
Pr. Cyril Huissoud
Secretary general CNGOF
Chef de service, HCL
Dr. Olivier Multon
Vice-President, Treasurer of the CNGOF, Director, Gynerisq
Praticien libéral, Santé Atlantique ELSAN
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
President of the Consortium
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Scientific Advisory Board for the Audiology Registry
Pr Vincent Darrouzet
Former President CNP ORL
CHU de Bordeaux
Pr. Hung THAI VAN
Chef de service
Hospices Civils de Lyon
Pr Jérôme Nevoux
Hôpital Bicêtre (APHP)
Pr Christophe Vincent
Chef de service, CHU de Lille
Dr Mary Daval
ENT surgeon
Deputy Head of Department, Fondation Rothschild
Dr Didier Bouccara
Liberal practitioner,
PH Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou
Pr Frédéric Venail
CHU de Montpellier
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
President of the Consortium
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Executive team
Dr. Jean-Pierre THIERRY – DPI
President, Consortium Résultat Patient
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Member of the Transparency Commission, HAS
Marie-Josée Augé-Caumon – DPI
Honnorary President
Treasurer of the Pharmacy National Professional Council
Florent Perin Dureau
Anesthesiologist, Medical advisor Rest Therapeutics
Former director of the neuroscience department, ANSM
Former director of research, Hôpital Foch
Supervisory Board
Anne-Marie Armanteras
President of the Supervisory Board, Consortium Résultat Patient
President, ANAP; former commission chair HAS, former DGOS,
former health advisor to the President of the French Republic
Pr. Laurent Degos
Founder and first President, HAS
Member of Académie des sciences
Pr. Isabelle Durand-Zaleski
Director, Health Economics Clinical Research Unit (APHP)
Former head of the evaluation department, HAS
Member of the Scientific Council, ATIH
Peter Pitts
President, Center for Medicine in the Public Interest
Former FDA Deputy Commissioner
Scientific Advisory Board for the Cataract Registry
Pr. Béatrice Cochener
President of the National Council of Ophthalmology Professionals
Ophtalmology Department, Brest University Hospital
Dr. Vincent Dédes
President of the Syndicat National des Ophtalmologistes de France (National Union of Ophthalmologists of France)
Cabinet d’Ophtalmologie des Flandres
Dr. François Lignereux
President of the Scientific Council
Institut Ophtalmologique Sourdille-Atlantique
Pr. Dominique Monnet
Vice President, SAFIR (Society of the French Association of Implants and Refractive Surgery)
Ophthalmology department, APHP Cochin Hospital
Dr. Pascal Rozot
President of the SAFIR (Society of the French Association of Implants and Refractive Surgery)
Ophthalmologist
Pr. Michel Weber
Chef de service
Ophthalmology department, Nantes University Hospital
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
President, Consortium Résultat Patient
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Scientific Advisory Board for the Carpal Tunnel Registry
Dr Philippe Bellemère
Ancien président de la Société Française de Chirurgie de la Main (SFCM)
Institut de la main santé Atlantique, Nantes
Dr Camilo Chaves
Chirurgien de la main
Clinique du Pré, Le Mans, Clinique Ambroise Paré, Neuilly sur Seine
Dr Thierry Dubert
Président du Conseil Scientifique
Hôpital Privé Paul d’Egine, Champigny sur Marnes
Mr Cédric Girault
Directeur Administratif & conseiller médico-social
Réseau Prévention Main Ile de France
Dr Yves Jacob
Président de la commission juridique de la SFCM
Clinique Claude Bernard, Metz
Pr Laurent Obert
1er Vice Président de la SFCM
Chef de service, CHU de Besançon
Dr Patrick Théron
Président CDOM 94, Secrétaire Général Adjoint CNOM, Président d’Honneur Réseau Prévention Main Ile de France
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
President, Consortium Résultat Patient
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Scientific Advisory Board for the Maternity Registry
Pr. Patrick Rozenberg
Délégué régional IDF CNGOF
Hôpital Américain de Paris
Pr. Philippe Deruelle
Secrétaire général du CNP GOGM
PU-PH, CHU Montpellier
Pr. Cyril Huissoud
Secrétaire général du CNGOF
Chef de service, HCL
Dr. Olivier Multon
Vice-président, Trésorier du CNGOF, Administrateur, Gynerisq
Praticien libéral, Santé Atlantique ELSAN
Pr. Corinne Dupont
Vice-doyenne maïeutique, HCL
Faculté de médecine, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
President, Consortium Résultat Patient
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Scientific Advisory Board for the Audiology Registry
Pr Vincent Darrouzet
Président du CNP ORL
CHU de Bordeaux
Pr. Hung THAI VAN
Chef de service Service d’audiologie et d’explorations otoneurologiques
Hospices Civils de Lyon
Pr Jérôme Nevoux
Hôpital Bicêtre (APHP)
Pr Christophe Vincent
CHU de Lille
Dr Mary Daval
Fondation Rothschild
Dr Didier Bouccara
Exercice libéral,
PH Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou
Pr Frédéric Venail
CHU de Montpellier
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
President, Consortium Résultat Patient
Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Management team
Marie-Josée Augé-Caumon
Président of the VBHC Consortium
Dr. Jean-Pierre THIERRY
Vice-President and Secretary General of the VBHC Consortium
Florent Perin Dureau
Anesthésiste réanimateur, Conseiller médical Rest Therapeutics Ancien directeur du département neurosciences à l’ANSM Ancien directeur de la recherche, Hôpital Foch
Supervisory Board
Anne-Marie Armanteras
Présidente du Conseil de surveillance, Consortium Résultat Patient Présidente de l’ANAP, ancienne présidente de commission HAS, ancienne DGOS, ancienne conseillère santé auprès du Président de la République
Pr. Laurent Degos
Fondateur et premier Président de la HAS Membre de l’Académie des sciences
Pr. Isabelle Durand-Zaleski
Directrice de l’unité de recherche clinique en économie de la santé (APHP) Ancienne cheffe du département d’évaluation de la HAS Membre du conseil scientifique de l’ATIH
Peter Pitts
President du Center for Medicine in the Public Interest Ancien commissaire adjoint de la FDA
Scientific Advisory Board for the Cataract Registry
Pr. Béatrice Cochener
President of the National Council of Ophthalmology Professionals Ophtalmology Department, Brest University Hospital
Dr. Vincent Dédes
President of the Syndicat National des Ophtalmologistes de France (National Union of Ophthalmologists of France) Cabinet d’Ophtalmologie des Flandres
Dr. François Lignereux
President of the Scientific Council Institut Ophtalmologique Sourdille-Atlantique
Pr. Dominique Monnet
Vice Président de la SAFIR Ophthalmology department, APHP Cochin Hospital
Dr. Pascal Rozot
President of the SAFIR (Society of the French Association of Implants and Refractive Surgery) Ophthalmologist
Pr. Michel Weber
Chef de service Ophthalmology department, Nantes University Hospital
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
Vice-President and Secretary General of the VBHC Consortium Medical advisor, France Assos Santé
Scientific Advisory Board for the Carpal Tunnel Registry
Dr Philippe Bellemère
Ancien président de la Société Française de Chirurgie de la Main (SFCM) Institut de la main santé Atlantique, Nantes
Dr Camilo Chaves
Chirurgien de la main Clinique du Pré, Le Mans, Clinique Ambroise Paré, Neuilly sur Seine
Dr Thierry Dubert
Président du Conseil Scientifique Hôpital Privé Paul d’Egine, Champigny sur Marnes
Mr Cédric Girault
Directeur Administratif & conseiller médico-social Réseau Prévention Main Ile de France
Dr Yves Jacob
Président de la commission juridique de la SFCM Clinique Claude Bernard, Metz
Pr Laurent Obert
1er Vice Président de la SFCM Chef de service, CHU de Besançon
Dr Patrick Théron
Président CDOM 94, Secrétaire Général Adjoint CNOM, Président d’Honneur Réseau Prévention Main Ile de France
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
Vice-Président du Consortium VBHC Conseiller médical, France Assos Santé
Scientific Advisory Board for the Maternity Registry
Pr. Patrick Rozenberg
Délégué régional IDF CNGOF Hôpital Américain de Paris
Pr. Philippe Deruelle
Secrétaire général du CNP GOGM PU-PH, CHU Montpellier
Pr. Cyril Huissoud
Secrétaire général du CNGOF Chef de service, HCL
Dr. Olivier Multon
Vice-président, Trésorier du CNGOF, Administrateur, Gynerisq Praticien libéral, Santé Atlantique ELSAN
Pr. Corinne Dupont
Vice-doyenne maïeutique, HCL Faculté de médecine, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
Vice-Président du Consortium VBHC Conseiller médical, France Assos Santé
Scientific Advisory Board for the Audiology Registry
Pr Vincent Darrouzet
Président du CNP ORL CHU de Bordeaux
Pr. Hung THAI VAN
Chef de service Service d’audiologie et d’explorations otoneurologiques Hospices Civils de Lyon
Pr Jérôme Nevoux
Hôpital Bicêtre (APHP)
Pr Christophe Vincent
CHU de Lille
Dr Mary Daval
Fondation Rothschild
Dr Didier Bouccara
Exercice libéral, PH Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou
Pr Frédéric Venail
CHU de Montpellier
Dr. Jean-Pierre Thierry
Vice-Président du Consortium VBHC Conseiller médical, France Assos Santé